NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Electric Blue, I wanted to love you, but you’re a creasing, smearing b*stard…

NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Electric Blue

NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Electric Blue

swatch against my skin- attempting to make this look like a legit makeup review

My actual eye pencil

Let me get one thing straight: I am generally a HUGE FAN of the makeup company NYX. Their products are sublimely affordable and of a higher quality (usually) than most drugstore brands.

If you want to know more about this company (which has since been sold to L’Oreal), read all about it here:


I love their Doll Eyes mascara- it holds tight, even in the most humid of circumstances. I also adore their lip glosses and BB cream and their fat eyebrow pencil with the ‘push up’ lighter color on the other side.

However, these jumbo pencils were a BIG let down. I own a several of these (thanks to great sales and an inability to stop buying makeup), but I am going to focus on my favorite, Electric Blue, for this post.

I admit, it may be partially my fault. I have extremely oily skin around my eyes as I get older. Raccoon eyes are a frequent problem now. I want to love this pencil so much- the color is so incredibly pigmented. It makes for nicely colored clown eyes an hour later. I did not try it yet with eye makeup primer, but that is my next goal.

Who am I kidding?  I have high-end eye pencils and gel pots in similar colors that don’t budge, even without primer.  I will probably stick to those.

I’d give this a 2.5 out of 5.

as much as it pains me to post this gross photo, I feel like I need to share my smeared, bloodshot raccoon eyes with the world…

For those who can’t figure out how to sharpen their jumbo pencils, see the video below-

Tutorial on how to sharpen their jumbo pencils: